Man Jumps Out of Moving Car During Argument with His Wife, Sues Her for Negligence

An Australian man who was left with “catastrophic” injuries after jumping out of a car driven by his wife has sued her for not slamming the brakes earlier, after seeing that he was about to jump.

This unbelievable incident took place in December of 2012, when Brian Lim, his wife, Eunkyung Cho, and their two children were driving home after a family dinner at a barbecue restaurant. The two spouses had began arguing after Mr. Lim spoke to an acquaintance at the restaurant, and their argument continued on the drive home. At one point, Ms. Cho allegedly made a critical comment about her husband’s parents. Lim responded by telling her that he wanted a divorce, but then, all of a sudden, opened the car door and jumped out before his five could grab him or slam her foot on the brake.

Photo: Mikes Photos/Pixabay

Court documents show that Eunkyung Cho was driving the family’s Mercedes-Benz at about 50 km/h, which may not sound very fast, but was enough to leave her husband with “catastrophic” injuries after his unexpected exit. Brian Lim, who is now “under legal incapacity” because of his injuries, sued his for negligence, claiming that his injuries would not have been as severe had she pushed the brake pedal as soon as she realized that he was about to jump.

Brian Lim took his case to the New South Wales District Court, where Judge David Wilson recently reached a verdict. He found that, as the driver, Eunkyung Cho had a duty to protect her husband while he was inside the car, but that duty did not extend to the harm he caused o himself by exiting the car the way he did.

Judge Wilson also argued that by suddenly slamming her foot on the break, Ms. Cho could have caused injury to her two young children as well as put other road users in danger. Plus, there is no way to prove that Brian Lim’s injuries would have been less severe had his wife pushed the break earlier, as he claims she should have.

“If the plaintiff wished to remove himself from the vehicle then a reasonable person in the position of the plaintiff would have waited until they arrived home before doing so,” Judge Wilson wrote in his verdict.

Mr. Lim was found guilty of contributory negligence and all damages he claimed were owed to him were reduced “by 100 percent”.

The plaintiff appealed the decision in the NSW Court of Appeal, but it agreed unanimously with the District Court judge’s ruling.


Posted in News        Tags: , , ,